8 Witchy Thrifted Candle Holder Flips For Under $10

This post may contain affiliate links, including those from Amazon Associates. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more about our affiliate policy.

---

 

There is a particular kind of magic in pulling a tarnished candlestick off a thrift store shelf for fifty cents.

Most people see clutter, but you and I see a vessel waiting patiently for candlelight and intention.

I have carried home more sad brass candlesticks and dusty glass votives than I can count, and every single one became something I now love.

These diy candle holder flips gather nine of those transformations in one place, each finished for under ten dollars.

All you need is a quiet afternoon, a few basic supplies, and a willingness to let humble objects become enchanted.

What You’ll Find in These DIY Candle Holder Flips

Here is a quick look at the nine thrift store crafts waiting for you below:

• A moon phase brass candlestick with hand painted lunar details
• A matte black gothic candelabra for instant drama
• A crystal crowned wooden candlestick
• A pressed flower glass votive that glows like stained light
• A wax dripped wine bottle holder with old world charm
• A celestial gold stamped pillar plate
• An amanita mushroom candlestick for cottage witch corners
• An herb and twine jar lantern

Every project starts with a secondhand base, so no two will ever look alike. If you love working this way, my guide to witchy DIY crafts with thrifted items pairs beautifully with this list.

Moon Phase Brass Candlestick

Brass candlesticks are the most common thrift shelf find, and they take paint beautifully. This flip turns one into a lunar altar piece in under an hour.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted brass candlestick
• Black chalk paint or matte acrylic
• Gold paint pen
• Small detail brush

Instructions:

1. Wash the candlestick with warm soapy water and let it dry completely.
2. Brush on two thin coats of black paint, letting each coat dry fully.
3. Draw a waxing to waning moon cycle down the stem with the gold pen.

A deep plum taper candle finishes the spell.

Matte Black Gothic Candelabra

An ornate candelabra in dated gold becomes pure gothic romance with one can of paint. The curvier and fussier the original, the better the result.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted metal candelabra
• Matte black spray paint
• Fine grit sandpaper

Instructions:

1. Lightly sand the surface so the paint has something to grip.
2. Spray thin, even coats outdoors, rotating between passes.
3. Let it cure overnight before adding candles.

Cluster it with mismatched black tapers for a moody mantel moment.

Crystal Crowned Wooden Candlestick

Chunky turned wood candlesticks are everywhere in thrift stores, and they make perfect pedestals for stone. This one holds a crystal instead of a flame.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted wooden candlestick
• Walnut stain or dark wax
• A large raw crystal or small cluster
• Strong clear adhesive

Instructions:

1. Deepen the wood tone with stain or dark wax, then buff dry.
2. Display your crystal in the candle cup

It becomes a tiny monument for an altar, witchy bookshelf, or windowsill.

Pressed Flower Glass Votive

Plain glass votives cost almost nothing secondhand, and pressed botanicals turn them luminous. Candlelight through petals feels like stained glass made by the garden.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted glass votive or small vase
• Pressed flowers and ferns
• Decoupage glue and a flat brush

Instructions:

1. Brush a thin layer of glue onto the outer glass.
2. Press flowers gently into place, smoothing air bubbles outward.
3. Seal with a final topcoat and dry for several hours.

If glass is your favorite canvas, my post on styling thrifted glass vessels is full of kindred ideas.

Wax Dripped Wine Bottle Holder

This is the oldest trick in the tavern, and it still enchants. A thrifted wine bottle plus dripping candles equals instant old world atmosphere.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted dark glass bottle
• Inexpensive drip taper candles
• A tray to catch wax

Instructions:

1. Soak off the label and dry the bottle thoroughly.
2. Seat a taper firmly in the neck and let it burn in short sessions.
3. Layer drips over several evenings until the wax cascades.

The bottle slowly becomes a sculpture that records every candlelit night.

Here is another method of painting the bottles first and then dripping a contrasting color from Victorian Deadrose:

Celestial Gold Stamped Pillar Plate

Thrifted saucers and small brass plates make lovely pillar candle bases. Gold stars transform them into little night skies.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted saucer or shallow plate
• Gold paint and a star stamp or stencil
• Matte sealer

Instructions:

1. Clean the plate and paint it a deep charcoal or midnight tone.
2. Stamp scattered gold stars across the surface and let dry.
3. Seal, then center a chunky pillar candle on top.

Find more fun witchy pottery painting ideas here.

Amanita Mushroom Cottage Witch Candlestick

This is witchy decor at its most whimsical, a red capped mushroom growing from a thrifted base. It never fails to make people smile.

What You’ll Need:

• Short thrifted wooden candlestick with a flat round top
• Red and cream acrylic paint
• Small round brush
• Air dry clay

Instructions:

1. Create a mushroom like shape and texture with the air dry clay on the top and bottom, building up the cap and stem. Smooth it out into the base of the candle holder.
2. Let dry overnight.
3. Paint the candle cup red and the stem a soft cream.
4. Dot white spots across the red cap and let everything dry.
5. Finish with matte sealer for a storybook look.

Tuck it beside a stack of well loved books and let it hold a beeswax taper.

Herb and Twine Jar Lantern

A humble jar becomes a hedge witch lantern with nothing but twine and dried herbs. This one is nearly free if your pantry is stocked.

What You’ll Need:

• Thrifted glass jar
• Natural twine
• Dried rosemary, lavender, or bay
• Tealight candle

Instructions:

1. Wrap the jar rim with twine and knot it securely.
2. Tuck small herb bundles under the wrapping.
3. Drop in a tealight and light it at dusk.

Line three along a porch rail and the whole evening softens.

A Little Candlelight Goes a Long Way

Nine flips, one afternoon at the thrift store, and less than the cost of a single new candle holder. That feels like a quiet kind of abundance to me.

Several of these make wonderful handmade witchy gifts, and a few could easily earn their keep among witchy crafts to sell at magical markets. If selling appeals to you, my roundup of profitable dollar store witchy crafts goes deeper.

Light one tonight and notice how the room changes. The magic was in the making, and now it lives in the flame.